Framing our values matters

During the campaign to pass ColoradoCare, many proponents felt that if they could just find the perfect slogan, the message would sink in across Colorado.

Not so, according to cognitive scientist George Lakoff.

Madeleine Jacobs, MD gives a KKTV Channel 11 reporter an self-described “earful” following a forum on health care July 21, 2017 in Colorado Springs as Mary Dmyterko looks on.

Our brains work in values frameworks, he says. And any fact, idea, or slogan that doesn’t fit into an existing moral values framework will be denied, ignored, or ridiculed.

According to Lakoff, conservative think tanks have invested heavily for the past 50 years in framing the conservative message. They’ve done this so well that even the media—who is trained to use the most common and simplest reference frames—has begun parroting conservative framing. Examples include “tax relief” and using “climate change” instead of “global warming.”

Conservatives haven’t waited until elections to hammer on their moral frameworks, either. They do it all the time.

Meanwhile, progressives have operated under the assumption that if we give people the facts clearly enough, they’ll “wake up.” According to Lakoff, people cannot even process a progressive idea such as universal health care unless they have a values framework for that idea.

The solution? All progressives, everywhere, need to begin articulating our values. According to Lakoff, this builds the moral frameworks in fellow progressives and strengthens progressive frameworks in those in the middle. The worst thing we can do, he argues, is to use conservative frames or messages to try and reach conservatives.

So how do we talk about our values? How do we build and strengthen a moral framework that supports win-win solutions like healthy communities free of toxins and universal health care?

We begin by sharing our own values around health care. And we’re looking for powerful values statements like those harnessed successfully in the movement for marriage equality, e.g. that everyone should be able to marry who they love.

Want to help the Earth and all people to enjoy the opportunity for life, liberty and happiness? Read Lakoff’s Don’t think of an Elephant and then get busy sharing your values widely.

Think you’ve found a short, clear, powerful values statement to define the universal health care movement? Share it!

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Framing our values matters

  1. Geoff Dolman says:

    It is unfathomable that our Congress, representing us [we the people] passes laws that forbid Medicare from negotiating with pharmaceutical manufacturers, requiring Medicare to pay whatever the pharma charges.

    Public health programs can work: 98% of the disbursements from Medicare go to providers to deliver healthcare. Private insurers pay only 80% on the average for direct patient care. The rest goes to profit and needless overhead.

  2. Geoff Dolman says:

    Business owners consider the cost increases of health benefits for their employees to be among the most serious threats to the continued ability to do business.

    Saving money while providing healthcare for everyone at a reasonable cost should make sense to all regardless of political affiliation or political beliefs.

    Universal coverage, less cost: what’s not to like.

  3. Geoff Dolman says:

    As a nation, we can no longer condemn 45,000 every year to death because they cannot afford to pay for a doctor visit.

    How can we have life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness without having healthcare for everyone at a reasonable cost?

    If everyone had access to healthcare at a reasonable cost, the public would not be forced to pay top dollar for indigent healthcare at ERs. We’d save money.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *